Half Service vs Full Service Airbnb Management: Which Option Maximizes Your Rental Income?

Half Service vs Full Service Airbnb Management: A Comprehensive Guide

Many vacation rental investors turn to professional management to save time, enhance performance, and enable remote investing. When exploring management options, property owners face a critical choice between two primary models: half service and full service Airbnb management.

What Half Service Airbnb Management Entails

Half service Airbnb management represents a professional property management approach that helps hosts automate and improve the most time-consuming aspects of running a short-term rental business.

The key distinction is that property owners remain actively involved in the management process and maintain significant control over operations and business growth.

Ideal Candidates for Half Service Management

This management style works well for investors who:

• Own properties close to their primary residence
• Have some available time to dedicate to their rental
• Possess hospitality experience or the necessary skills to interact with guests and vendors
• Desire to participate in decisions regarding their vacation rental

Before selecting this option, owners should understand they’ll need to allocate time to their property (though less than DIY hosts) and handle various responsibilities, primarily related to property preparation, housekeeping coordination, inspections, and maintenance.

Half service management isn’t ideal for investors seeking completely passive income or those with properties far from home, as it may require significant travel to ensure everything runs smoothly.

Pricing Structure

Half service Airbnb managers typically charge between 10% and 15% of monthly revenue, including cleaning fees. While this appears reasonable, remember that hosts must remain actively involved in property management since services are partial.

Some managers may charge additional fees for services beyond their standard package.

Services Typically Included

Half service management usually covers:

• Listing and distribution across major booking platforms (Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com) and niche websites
• Continuous listing optimization for Airbnb search visibility
• Professional photography
• Dynamic pricing and revenue management
• Marketing and advertising (content, SEO, social media, email, paid ads)
• 24/7 guest communication and support
• Reservation management
• Check-in/check-out coordination via smart locks
• Guest review collection and management
• Tax collection and remittance to owners
• Property damage and liability protection

However, these managers typically don’t provide:

• Interior design and furnishing
• Assistance with licenses and permits
• Housekeeping (though some help find cleaning services)
• Regular property inspections
• Maintenance and repairs coordination

This division of responsibilities makes half service viable only for owners willing to remain active in property management with sufficient time and skills.

Leading Half Service Companies

Major players in the half service Airbnb management sector include:

Evolve: Managing over 30,000 properties across numerous US markets, Evolve offers core services and connections to local businesses for cleaning, restocking, inspections, and maintenance. They charge 10% of rental revenue for their Core plan and 15% for their Plus plan with additional tools.

RedAwning: Working with more than 20,000 short-term rentals across US beach areas, mountain resorts, cities, and luxury destinations, RedAwning provides basic services plus assistance with direct booking websites. They partner with PriceLabs for dynamic pricing and Turno for cleaner management, charging 10% of bookings.

Half service management helps hosts save considerable time on daily tasks while increasing bookings and revenue through dynamic pricing, professional marketing, and responsive communication—making it suitable for owners who want control while reducing their workload.

What Full Service Airbnb Management Delivers

Full service Airbnb management involves comprehensive professional management by a third-party company covering all aspects necessary for successful vacation rental operations.

Unlike half service options, full service managers assume complete control over all processes, allowing investors to enjoy passive income and optimized performance. From the owner’s perspective, this passive approach means relinquishing control over business operations.

Ideal Candidates for Full Service Management

Full-service property management suits:

• Owners with properties in different states
• Those lacking hospitality qualifications or interest
• Individuals with full-time jobs and limited availability
• Investors seeking truly passive real estate income

This approach enables profit maximization since the best short-term rental markets often aren’t where owners live, and full service management facilitates remote investing.

Hosts considering this option should recognize they’ll have limited control over their property. Most operational decisions and strategic planning will be handled by the property manager, though reputable companies align strategies with owner priorities and expectations.

Pricing Structure

Full service Airbnb managers typically charge between 25% and 40% of monthly rental income, with variations based on market, property type, services provided, monthly rate, and agreement duration.

While this represents a significant portion of revenue, owners receive comprehensive management, passive income, and improved performance—potentially maintaining or even increasing actual cash flow.

Beyond the management fee, hosts sometimes pay extra for design, furnishing, photography, linens, amenity maintenance, and insurance. Some companies also charge onboarding and early-termination fees, though these aren’t standard industry practice.

Services Typically Included

Full service vacation rental management aims to handle all necessary responsibilities, including:

• Interior design and furnishing (varies by company)
• Property preparation for listing and guest readiness
• Smart technology installation (varies by company)
• Legal support for licensing (varies by company)
• Professional photography
• Short-term rental insurance access (varies by company)
• Listing creation, optimization, and distribution
• Comprehensive marketing and advertising
• Dynamic pricing for revenue optimization
• 24/7 guest services and communication
• Guest screening
• Check-in/check-out coordination
• Booking management
• Cleaning, laundry, and restocking between guests
• Property maintenance (varies by company)
• Regular inspections
• Maintenance coordination
• Tax collection and remittance
• Accounting support
• Financial reporting

Service offerings vary between companies, so owners should clarify exactly what’s included and associated costs before selecting a manager.

Leading Full Service Companies

Top full service Airbnb management companies include:

Summer: Ranked as a leading full service vacation rental manager covering everything from design to maintenance. Their properties outperform at least 95% of comparable listings in each market. Fees start at 20% of booking revenue (excluding cleaning fees) with no additional charges. Design and furnishing services start at $10,000.

Vacasa: North America’s largest short-term rental management company, overseeing 44,000+ properties across 400 destinations. They offer end-to-end management with optional services charged separately. Fees are customized, but reviews indicate rates consistently above 25%, sometimes reaching 45% of monthly revenue.

Casago: Managing approximately 5,000 vacation rentals across 60 popular destinations. Services are comprehensive but exclude design, furnishing, HVAC maintenance, pest control, snow removal, and certain annual maintenance tasks. Pricing structure is determined after property analysis.

Air Concierge: Provides end-to-end management for nightly and extended rentals. They cover most expected services except cleaning and maintenance. Fees range from 10-25% depending on contract duration, stay length, and property type, plus onboarding and early-termination fees (up to $7,500 for one-year agreements).

SkyRun Vacation Rentals: A full service manager operating in multiple cities across 15 states, working with various property sizes. They lack design, furnishing, tax services, and insurance offerings. Pricing is customizable without published ranges.

Full service management enables passive real estate income while ensuring professional property oversight, leading to enhanced performance and revenue—making it popular among beginners, part-time investors, and those with multiple properties.

Key Differences Between Management Models

While both management types help hosts increase income more easily, significant distinctions exist between the models:

Host Responsibilities

Half service management streamlines operations but requires owner involvement, while full service management transfers most responsibilities to the manager. With companies like Evolve and RedAwning, investors still handle property preparation, licensing, housekeeping, and maintenance. With Summer, Vacasa, and Casago, owners can largely enjoy passive income.

Host Control

Half service allows owners to retain business control, while full service means relinquishing that control. With Evolve and RedAwning, hosts decide on cleaning providers, supplies, and property improvements. With SkyRun and Casago, the company determines property preparation and maintenance schedules. However, quality full service companies like Summer ensure alignment with owner requirements and often exceed expectations.

Fees

Half service providers charge lower fees (10-15% of revenue), but owners must account for additional services like housekeeping and maintenance, making total costs comparable to full service management. Full service fees vary significantly—Summer starts at 20% of booking revenue, while Vacasa sometimes exceeds 45%.

Results

Full service companies generally achieve better performance improvements due to greater process control and comprehensive professional hospitality services. Evolve helps owners earn approximately 18% more revenue, while Summer ensures properties outperform at least 95% of comparable listings in each market.

Understanding these differences helps hosts determine the right solution for their specific needs.

Pros and Cons of Half Service Management

Half service management offers distinct advantages and disadvantages that hosts should consider when evaluating this strategy.

Advantages

• Business operations automation and organization
• Time savings
• Enhanced performance
• Increased revenue
• Control over business decisions and growth
• Lower management fees
• Greater share of monthly income retained

Disadvantages

• Regular active involvement required
• Basic hospitality skills needed
• Limited to investing near home
• Revenue sharing with manager

Based on these factors, half service management suits hosts with one or few properties, flexible schedules, nearby investments, and desire for business control.

Pros and Cons of Full Service Management

End-to-end Airbnb management offers significant benefits alongside some drawbacks that owners should carefully evaluate.

Advantages

• Truly passive income
• No involvement in daily operations
• Increased monthly income
• Ability to invest in any market
• Scalability potential
• No specific skills or experience required

Disadvantages

• Limited control over business processes
• Risk of partnering with an incompetent manager
• Surrendering a significant revenue portion
• Some responsibilities remain (e.g., tax filing)

Considering these factors, full service management works well for owners with large rental portfolios, remote investors, hosts with full-time jobs, and anyone seeking passive real estate income.

See also: 7 Signs You Need a Property Manager for Your Rental Home (And How to Choose the Right One)

Choosing the Right Management Approach

The comparison between half service and full service Airbnb management reveals that both approaches offer viable benefits for different investor types. Those who enjoy managing their short-term rental business but need help streamlining processes should explore half service options. Meanwhile, hosts willing to exchange control for passive income should investigate top vacation rental management companies in their target markets.

Your investment goals, time availability, proximity to your property, and desired level of involvement should guide your decision between these management styles. By carefully weighing these factors against the benefits each approach offers, you can select the management solution that best aligns with your short-term rental strategy and personal circumstances.

Click here to learn more about how we can elevate your short-term rental experience.