8 Best Airbnb Alternatives for Better Vacation Rentals in 2025
Searching for Vacation Rentals Beyond Airbnb? Here’s Where to Look in 2025
If you’re a homeowner in Denver or just someone keen on finding the perfect getaway, you’re already aware that vacation rentals have reshaped the way people travel. In neighborhoods across Colorado and all over the country, the conversation often turns to one giant: Airbnb. Yet as many travelers and property owners around Denver will tell you, the experience can feel hit-or-miss—or simply not as good as it should. Luckily, new players are carving out their own corners and providing serious competition.
Travelers and rental owners in Denver and Colorado have been quick to notice that local charm doesn’t always come from big-name platforms. Sometimes the best experiences—and revenue—are found with smaller, specialized options. Whether you’re renting out your property or booking a family trip, local expertise and a streamlined process matter more than ever in 2025.
1. Vrbo: User-Friendly and Rewards-Driven
Imagine a platform that feels a bit more like Airbnb’s close cousin, but nerdier—in a good way. Vrbo is exactly that. While its listings don’t match Airbnb’s scale, what stands out for both owners and travelers is quality over quantity. Vrbo’s loyalty program, One Key, rewards guests for stays not only on Vrbo, but also throughout Expedia Group’s suite of sites. Users earn two percent back in OneKeyCash on eligible stays, which makes it possible to enjoy perks across Vrbo, Expedia, and Hotels.com.
One helpful tip: Vrbo’s “total price” filter offers upfront pricing, meaning users get a real picture of their costs without surprise fees at checkout. It’s a big win for anyone who’s tired of hidden costs eating into vacation budgets or property revenue.
“Vrbo might not have as many listings as Airbnb, but its hidden treasures are worth the search—and the loyalty program makes coming back an easy choice.”
Property owners, however, should be aware that Vrbo’s cancellation policies can sometimes feel confusing, and customer service isn’t always as responsive as Airbnb’s. There are also no options for renting out single rooms or shared spaces. But for full-property rentals, the platform offers a straightforward experience—often with better value.
2. Whimstay: The Go-To Spot for Last-Minute Bargains
Whimstay is the answer for spontaneous planners and travelers who just don’t want to pay full price. Think of it as the vacation rental world’s version of HotelTonight. While originally only open to professionally managed rentals, as of July 2025, individual hosts can now list their properties through Whimstay using their existing Airbnb links. That means a broader range of options, often at lower costs than you’d find elsewhere.
What really makes Whimstay shine in Denver and similar cities? Regularly-discounted listings averaging 10-20% below standard rates. And for short-term rental owners eyeing better occupancy rates, offering a last-minute spot on Whimstay can fill those unexpected vacancies. It’s fast, too—same-day bookings and instant confirmations make the process friction-free for both guests and hosts who want to keep things simple.
3. Booking.com: International Reach, Professionally Managed
Known for global hotel searches, Booking.com also features thousands of vacation rentals—especially outside the U.S. If you’re traveling to major cities across Europe or Asia, you’ll find apartments in buildings managed by professionals. For Denver hosts, that means there’s a growing group of potential international guests hunting for hassle-free stays.
While Booking.com properties might not offer the quirky design or local flavor of some Airbnb finds, the trade-off is often smoother check-in, professionalism, and a process big city guests have grown used to. It’s ideal for those who appreciate predictability—sometimes, after a delayed flight, that’s all anyone wants.
4. Vacasa: Local Expertise and High Standards
Vacasa takes a hands-on approach to vacation rentals, similar to what Simplify Renting does for Denver-area homeowners. The platform partners with property owners, offering everything from listing management to in-person cleanings and 24/7 guest support. Owners benefit from local teams who understand neighborhood trends and guest expectations.
- Consistent quality: Every Vacasa property goes through regular inspections and follows detailed cleaning checklists, ensuring guests (and owners) know exactly what to expect.
- Redemption with points: Partnerships with organizations like Marriott International and Wyndham Rewards allow some guests to book with loyalty points rather than cash.
- Diverse selection: With a broad portfolio of 40,000 properties across North America and destinations like Costa Rica and Belize, Vacasa offers everything from mountain cabins to beachfront condos.
- App-driven experience: Guests receive check-in details via text and app notifications, while the app streamlines checkout and support requests. Customer support is always available, day or night.
The main downside? Limited presence outside the U.S., Canada, and a handful of other countries. In terms of size, Vacasa can’t match Airbnb’s millions of listings, but it’s the preferred choice for travelers (and property owners) who want high standards and personal attention.
5. Hipcamp: Camping and Glamping with Personality
If your heart’s set on something outdoorsy—think yurts near Boulder or Airstreams in the Rockies—Hipcamp has you covered. The platform is loved by road trippers and adventurers searching for approachable and budget-friendly stays. Hosts can list everything from simple tent sites to quirky cabins.
There’s a trade-off, though: The rustic appeal means you might find surprises—both good and bad. If you’re comfortable with basic amenities and want to stand out as a property owner, Hipcamp brings fun and flexibility. Guests looking for a true Colorado experience often discover gems here that no big-box hotel can provide.
6. Homes & Villas by Marriott Bonvoy: Loyalty Perks Meet Vacation Rentals
Marriott’s entry into the vacation rental world has turned heads, especially among points enthusiasts. If you have a stash of Bonvoy® points (perhaps from a credit card), this is one of the only ways to redeem them on home rentals with hotel-level quality standards. Travelers can earn or spend Marriott points across a curated portfolio, making the booking process seamless for anyone familiar with the brand.
The catch? The number of available rentals is small compared to giants like Airbnb, and the point value for redemptions can be lower than with standard hotel rooms. However, for guests who want to stick with Marriott—and for property owners open to this level of professional management—it’s an attractive option, particularly in upscale or luxury markets.
“Homes & Villas by Marriott Bonvoy bridges the gap between the comfort of a vacation home and the reliability of a trusted hotel brand.”
7. Local Vacation Rental Management Companies
In places like Denver—and countless small towns—local vacation rental managers are thriving. Why? They know the neighborhoods, offer boots-on-the-ground support, and can react quickly to changing regulations or local trends. Many communities even require vacation rentals to be handled by local operations to stay compliant with city or HOA guidelines.
Guests enjoy quick responses, maintenance help that’s truly nearby, and a layer of local trust that national platforms can’t always establish. And for homeowners, partnering with a locally focused, full-service manager like Simplify Renting means maximizing income while sidestepping the common headache of rental management.
Not finding a match on the big sites? A quick web search for local companies often turns up unique rentals—with all the support and personality you’d expect from a business rooted right in your community.
8. Resorts Offering Private Cabins and Cottages
Sometimes, you want all the perks of a resort—pool, gym, 24-hour staff—without giving up the privacy of a detached home. Enter: the hybrid approach. If you’ve ever stayed in a cabin at Big Cedar Lodge in Missouri or checked into a Florida resort rental with a private kitchen and even an indoor slide, you know how charming this can be.
This growing trend is making waves in 2025, especially as families and group travelers eye relaxation plus adventure. Hilton has even started letting guests earn or spend reward points on private home rentals thanks to partnerships with properties like Evermore Orlando Resort. It’s the best of both worlds: unique, spacious accommodations and dependable, resort-level service.
Just keep in mind—these options can be pricier than standard rentals, but the experience often justifies the spend with bonus amenities and extra security.
Tips for Choosing Your Best Fit
Airbnb might overshadow vacation rental choices, but don’t get stuck wearing someone else’s crown. When searching for your next place—whether it’s a Colorado cabin or a downtown condo—ask yourself what you value most. Is it customer support, the chance to earn rewards, or a local touch you won’t find with nationwide platforms?
- Always compare final costs. Beyond nightly rates, check taxes and guest or resort fees. Extra costs can tip the scales.
- Prioritize your needs. Loyalty programs, ease of booking, cancellation flexibility, and personal support all matter—especially when something unexpected pops up.
- Think local. Denver’s short-term rental market, like many others, benefits from personalized management and real community connections. A local company may be your best bet for a hassle-free experience.
Vacation Rentals Keep Evolving
In 2025’s fast-changing travel scene, more options mean better experiences for everyone. Airbnb still has size on its side, but each of these alternatives brings something worthwhile for specific needs, whether that’s last-minute deals, meaningful rewards, or local support. The key is to shop smart and keep your expectations in line with your priorities.
Next time you’re searching for a getaway—or looking for a way to earn from your own property—remember: the “right” vacation rental doesn’t always have a logo you recognize. Sometimes, it just feels right.